Thursday, August 6, 2015
Gary Habermas Shows Why the 'Minimal Facts' of Jesus' Death Can't Establish the Resurrection
Sunday, July 6, 2014
Bart Ehrman on What We Can and Cannot Know About the Resurrection
These are relatively mundane points. They appear in the earliest Christian sources, require no commitment to an actual resurrection or actual postmortem appearances, and there is something to be said for their role in Christianity's historical survival.
More interesting are the two things Dr. Ehrman says he has changed his mind on regarding what we cannot know about the resurrection. Like his colleague John Dominic Crossan, Professor Ehrman now believes that the tradition of an honorable burial of Jesus is doubtful. He makes note of the suspicious backstory of Joseph of Arimathea, a member of the same Jewish council that condemned Jesus to death, absent from the early Christian creeds, and a figure who is progressively portrayed across the four gospels as more and more of a sympathizer to the Christian cause. Citing a handful of ancient examples, he observes that Roman crucifixion victims were not usually given proper burials because humiliation was an important part of the practice, intending to deter potential criminals from committing acts of rebellion against Rome. Those who were crucified were often laid in common graves or left to decay and be eaten by scavenging animals.
It is sometimes remarked that Jesus was buried by Joseph in accordance with Jewish law, since the Sabbath was close at hand. Deuteronomy 21:22-23 gives instruction in this vein, but as Dr. Ehrman points out, it's an open question of whether or not the Romans, particularly Pilate, would have respected such a rule. Though the Pharisees and the Jewish Sanhedrin had accused Jesus of blasphemy, the charges brought against him in front of Pilate were more political - inciting crowds, forbidding payment of taxes to Caesar, and claiming to be king (Luke 23:1-3). If Jesus was executed as an insurgent, under certain circumstances perhaps he would have been left unburied. If, however, he was executed in accordance with Jewish law, it's not so obvious where he was buried. In a chapter of the anthology The Empty Tomb: Jesus Beyond the Grave, Peter Kirby writes that there is some evidence for a dishonorable burial tradition in passages like Mark 12:8 and Acts 13:27-29, which allude to Jesus being buried by his enemies rather than by his followers. [1]
The second thing Professor Ehrman has come to change his mind about is the empty tomb tradition. Like many before him, he draws attention to the fact that no empty tomb is mentioned in the earliest New Testament sources, the writings of Paul. Christian apologists often claim that a burial followed by a raising from the dead a la 1 Corinthians 15:4 implies an empty tomb. Yet Ehrman elsewhere argues that Paul interpreted the resurrection in a spiritual and not a physical sense, which would make an unoccupied tomb unnecessary. Dr. Ehrman also counters another apologetic claim that the discovery of the tomb by women lends credibility, since no one at that time would have made up such a story, as distrusted as women were. One can rightly question why we ought to think the gospel authors intended the resurrection narratives to hold up as any sort of legal or quasi-legal testimonials. The gospels come from oral traditions, they're not court documents. Additionally, women may have been so featured in the resurrection narratives because they were the ones tasked with preparing the bodies of the dead, or because, as some sources note, the Christian sect was especially popular with women. As the author says, this objection seems to rest on nothing but a lack of imagination.
Bart doesn't offer much comment on the empty tomb, but after some reflection this doesn't quite seem as disappointing as it might initially seem. The case for the empty tomb is razor thin when you think about it, relying pretty exclusively on texts which scholars have known for a good while to be dependent on one another. [2] Earlier texts outside of this literary dependence, like the Pauline epistles, do not mention an empty tomb, or any of the familiar details of the empty tomb tradition. Furthermore, there is the strange fact that there is no indication from any ancient sources of veneration of Jesus' tomb - a point I'd like to have seen Ehrman make - which is baffling especially with characters like Paul, who never was able to meet Jesus before his crucifixion, who preached the extreme importance of the resurrection (1 Corinthians 15:17), and presumably would have wanted to see his lord and savior's tomb, if it had existed in his time.
Consider how damaging these two areas of doubt are to the case for the resurrection, even against the three areas of confidence Dr. Ehrman notes. The disciples may have believed that Jesus rose from the dead, that he appeared to them after his death, and that he was god in some sense, but why should any of this compel us to believe as they did? People believe things for all sorts of reasons. People can be mistaken, people can hallucinate, as Professor Ehrman discusses in chapter five. When most of us hear of a body missing from a grave site, we don't think resurrection, we think grave robbers, we think the body has been moved, or that we came to the wrong site. Ironically, even the gospels have the followers of Jesus entertaining some of these explanations first, finding the resurrection just too unbelievable (John 20:2, Luke 24:11).
If it's doubtful Jesus was buried, and doubtful there was ever an empty tomb, then what we're left with sounds an awful lot like what Dan Dennett has described as "belief in belief". Whatever the disciples actually experienced, whatever was or was not actually going on, one chooses to believe in the disciples' belief that god raised Jesus from the dead. Of course, this is what I have seen the picture to be for a good while now, and the same assessment has been made by many other atheists, many biblical scholars, many philosophers, and many non-Christians in general. I'm pleased to see Bart Ehrman planting himself more firmly in this camp.
However, the question remains: if belief in belief is all that's required, why not belief in Mormonism, in Islam, in Buddhism, in Hinduism, or in the traditions of any other religion? Despite what William Lane Craig, Gary Habermas, and other apologists may call things like the belief in an empty tomb or the belief in postmortem visions, they are not facts. The reality of it has always been belief in belief, particularly belief in the reliability of uncorroborated beliefs. But without facts, without empirical data, without some independent means of assessment, Christian belief in the resurrection has nothing substantial distinguishing it from similar belief in the uncorroborated traditions of other religions. Building on his extant work questioning the reliability of the New Testament, Dr. Ehrman's latest book offers quite a bit of food for thought.
------------
Sources:
1. Peter Kirby, in The Empty Tomb: Jesus Beyond the Grave (2005, Prometheus), p. 246-247.
2. Stephen C. Carlson, Synoptic Problem FAQ (2004).
Tuesday, July 9, 2013
What's the Probability of Resurrection?
Sunday, January 6, 2013
The Revolutionary Message of Jesus
------------
Do a simple Google search for 'Jesus revolutionary message', and you will find countless Christian websites all claiming that the teachings of Jesus Christ were new and unique for their time, and remain so still today. Some argue that the figure in the four gospels was a perfect symbol of peace on earth, while others contend that he was a political and social extremist who defied the Roman empire and horrified the religious leadership of the day. Perhaps the most fascinating thing about the character of Jesus is that he is not so easy to pigeonhole, as the scriptures of the bible offer support for a wide variety of views. In this article, I aim to explore these different characterizations of Jesus and determine just how revolutionary his teachings were.
I. The Prince of Peace?
Christians believe that Isaiah 9:6 references Jesus Christ when it speaks of the 'Prince of Peace'. The title has since made it into countless worship songs and other Christian paraphernalia, as believers proclaim their messiah to be the greatest standard for peace that ever walked the earth. Jesus is often portrayed as a beacon of purest love, opposed to all violence and injustice, but how well do his own words in the gospels confirm this?
In these verses, the 'Prince of Peace' makes it abundantly clear that his teachings are not for those who desire peace. Christianity will divide families and friends, because God demands that you love him more than your own parents or your own children.'Do not suppose that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I did not come to bring peace, but a sword. For I have come to turn "a man against his father, a daughter against her mother, a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law -- a man's enemies will be the members of his own household." Anyone who loves his father or mother more than me is not worthy of me; anyone who loves his son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me; and anyone who does not take his cross and follow me is not worthy of me. Whoever finds his life will lose it, and whoever loses his life for my sake will find it.'
-Matthew 10:34-39
Beginning in Luke 19:11, Jesus tells the parable of a king who lends out some of his money to several servants. Even though his subjects hated him and did not wish him to be king (verse 14), and one of them rightfully accused the king of taking what is not his (verse 21), the merciful dictator still decided to slay his ungrateful subjects in the end of the tale. It should not be too difficult to understand that this parable symbolizes the reign of Jesus over humanity, and those who do not accept him as their savior will be cast into hell on judgment day.But those enemies of mine who did not want me to be king over them -- bring them here and kill them in front of me. -Luke 19:27
It has been said that actions speak louder than words, and not only does Jesus vocalize his opposition to peace, but his actions do support his statements, as we find in the book of John...
Why would someone devoted to non-violent protest cause such a ruckus in a public place of worship? Jesus could have simply preached against the atrocities he observed in the temple, but instead he chose to physically assault both humans and animals, in addition to destroying whatever he did not like to see in the building. To some people, this action of Jesus is an example of his fanaticism against the establishment, which leads me to the second characterization that is often applied to Christ.When it was almost time for the Jewish Passover, Jesus went up to Jerusalem. In the temple courts he found men selling cattle, sheep and doves, and others sitting at tables exchanging money. So he made a whip out of cords, and drove all from the temple area, both sheep and cattle; he scattered the coins of the money changers and overturned their tables. To those who sold doves he said, 'Get these out of here! How dare you turn my Father's house into a market!'
-John 2:13-16
II. Jesus the Anarchist
Many times the suggestion has been made that Jesus Christ was crucified for defying the authority of the Roman government or for causing general unrest with his 'revolutionary' ideas. However, there is little evidence in the gospels to depict Jesus as some kind of socio-political warrior, fighting for the people against the established order. When asked about paying taxes to Caesar in Matthew 22:16-22, Jesus says, "Give to Caesar what is Caesar's, and to God what is God's". This statement is unremarkable and non-revolutionary, as Christ clearly instructs his followers to obey their government and pay their taxes, while reserving their hearts and minds for God. This submission to authority is also addressed by the apostle Paul in Romans 13:1-2...
As self-explanatory as these verses may seem, there are still dozens of websites, books and articles devoted to characterizing Jesus as a political activist and even an anarchist. Through imaginative reinterpretations, they pretend that Jesus and Paul weren't really advocating obedience to government, just saying it because they were in a bind. If Jesus had told his followers that they could disregard the commands of Caesar, he would've been killed on the spot... right? There is another angle to this issue that deserves examination.Everyone must submit himself to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established. The authorities that exist have been established by God. Consequently, he who rebels against the authority is rebelling against what God has instituted, and those who do so will bring judgment on themselves.
When someone asserts that Jesus was crucified for defying the local authorities, they usually mean one of two things:
- He was executed by the Romans for challenging the governing laws/values of their empire.
- He was executed for stirring up conflicts among the Jewish population, by blaspheming and teaching others to blaspheme.
Neither of these perspectives are concretely supported by scripture or by history. The Romans were well known to be very tolerant of other religions and beliefs, and typically incorporated some of them into their own doctrines after they conquered a people or region. In and around Jesus' day, there were vast numbers of sects and groups known as Roman mystery cults, which professed to have secret, divine knowledge [1]. If the Romans did not fear these cults or their many different gods, then why would they have objected to the teachings of Christianity? As we have already seen, Jesus taught nothing that was radically against the empire. It is strange to think the Romans would've felt threatened by the small Christian sect even if Jesus had been calling for the overthrow of the government. When Simon Bar-Kokhba led his revolt against the empire and reclaimed much of Judea a few decades after Jesus in 132 AD, Rome was largely unprepared and had to be petitioned by the local authorities to send more reinforcements [2]. Why would they have cared about the small following of a Jewish carpenter who had not yet resorted to full-blown acts of violence?
If the Romans were not the ones lobbying for Christ's crucifixion, then maybe it was the Jews. But again, for a few reasons this seems unlikely. Jesus was far from the only person claiming to be the Jewish messiah in those days. We have several historical references to over a dozen messiahs from before and after the alleged lifetime of Christ [3]. Of these self-proclaimed saviors, the ones who were eventually executed were executed for leading violent rebellions against the Roman empire, not for blaspheming against Jewish beliefs. The New Testament mentions numerous stoning incidents as punishment for blasphemy, so it is also a wonder why the Jewish crowd or the Jewish leaders would not have simply stoned Jesus to death on the spot for blaspheming, instead of taking their case to the Roman authorities who often seemed unsympathetic to Jewish concerns.
Could a man named Jesus have been executed for revolting against the Roman empire? It is possible, but with the evidence we do have, it seems fairly improbable.
III. The Good News is Old News
When Christians say Jesus was a revolutionary teacher, many of them mean that the ideas he advocated were revolutionary in his time. Perhaps they were a bit of a culture shock for first century Palestine, but Jesus did not teach anything that was new to the rest of the world too. The Golden Rule predates Jesus Christ by several centuries, his famous instruction to "love thy neighbor as thyself" can be traced back to Hebrew scripture (Proverbs 24:17, 25:21), and his advice to "love your enemies" in Matthew 5:44 is not original either. The first century philosopher and playwright Seneca the Younger wrote:
Believers do indeed love to imagine that their savior was the first and the last of great thinkers and moral sages, but he was only one among many throughout history, and he was certainly not the pinnacle. Jesus was not the first character to willingly die for a principle (Socrates did this several centuries before Christ), and he was definitely not the first person to equate himself with God, as Egyptian pharaohs, Roman emperors, Chinese emperors, and countless others had done as early as 2,000-3,000 years prior. The Jesus figure may be unique and original in his use of parables, but all of his claims and teachings may be followed back to another individual from an earlier time. I am not arguing that Jesus intentionally imitated their doctrines, but only that the character in the four gospels of the bible was not as revolutionary as some would lead us to believe.Someone gets angry with you. Challenge him with kindness in return. Enmity immediately tumbles away when one side lets it fall. [4]
It may be that many Christians choose to hold such an idealistic view of Jesus because acknowledging other similar messiahs and teachers might provoke them to seriously question the divinity of their beloved lord. One can imagine how it would be difficult to believe in a god or supernatural savior who only rehashes old wisdom and brings nothing new to the theological or philosophical arenas. There were plenty of important issues that the biblical Jesus left unexplored, which we could possibly expect a truly divine and moral leader to have covered. There is no clear admonition of rape, spousal/child abuse, child molestation (which the Greeks were well known for engaging in around Jesus' time), or any number of other unspeakable acts that are curiously left out of the 10 Commandments as well.
Jesus was no revolutionary, not in a peaceful sense or in a political sense. If he existed and spoke the words the bible attributes to him, he was perhaps just a man teaching from the heart. In many ways he sought to conform some of his lessons to the Judaic traditions and customs of the time, yet he also tried to depart from them in other ways. He was one among several self-professed messiahs attempting to change minds and practices in the first century. Thanks to the endorsement from certain individuals and empires, his religion has continued on to the modern day. He has made his impact, and maybe that is the revolutionary part of it in a sense, but let's not forget that a long-standing legacy in no way implies a greater chance of truth in the person or his message.
2. Schoenberg, S. The Bar-Kokhba Revolt. Jewish Virtual Library. Retrieved Mar. 7, 2009.
3. Lendering, J. Messiah (overview). Livius.org. Retrieved Mar. 7, 2009.
4. Seneca. De Ira, 2.
Saturday, June 16, 2012
Women at the Empty Tomb
The big problem with this idea is that it rests on an assumption about Mark's intent with the material (I mention Mark because most scholars consider it the earliest gospel and one source used by Matthew and Luke; John's reference to women at the tomb may or may not be independent of the synoptics, but could just as well come from some other source material). In his debate with Richard Carrier, Mike Licona argues that if the gospel authors had invented the empty tomb story, they would have portrayed the male disciples as the first at the tomb, because it would have been more believable in that era.
However, it's not at all evident that the gospel accounts treat the women as witnesses. To whom are they witnesses? The male disciples? The reader? Would first century readers have recognized their presence as constituting some kind of witness to the resurrection? How could this be when, as the apologists point out, women were not valued as witnesses in that time? The whole thing makes very little sense. Mark tells us that the women went to the tomb to ceremonially anoint the body (16:1), as was the custom of the day. Their presence in the narrative doesn't appear to indicate anything more than the observance of Jewish customs. In fact, we might argue that without this element, the story would have seemed more suspicious at the time.
But perhaps even this much effort is not necessary to debunk this claim. The Jewish historian Josephus shows no discomfort when he relies on the testimonies of two women regarding the events at Gamala and Masada. Richard Carrier provides a number of additional cases of trusted female witnesses, and also exposes some of the weak arguments made in this area by apologists. [1] If there is no veracity to the idea that women were not considered reliable in the ancient world, then this argument for the historicity and reliability of the resurrection account collapses. Nonetheless, countless apologists continue to peddle this nonsense, while - I'm sorry to say - few skeptics seem to properly address it.
Saturday, December 11, 2010
A Tyrant to Value Above All
When it comes to the difference between moderate and fundamentalist Christians, I think this quote says it all. We often hear, even from some liberal believers, that putting Christ first in our lives is the most important decision we can make. The gist behind Rick Warren's bestseller, The Purpose Driven Life, is that the only way to lead a truly fulfilling life is by placing Jesus at the center of it. The same sentiments are echoed by Pat Robertson and others who have called America to 'get back to god,' as well as politicians who believe their god would never let global warming harm the earth and that our prosperity as a nation is divinely tied into our relationship with Israel. Then there are the believers who refuse medical treatment for their own children, leading to numerous deaths that could have easily been prevented if welfare had been put before faith.
Are these examples of an extremist interpretation? According to the gospels, Jesus himself even explained that unless one "comes to me and does not hate their father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters - yes, even their own life - such a person cannot be my disciple" (Luke 14:26). In other words, Christ has to come first, even above your own family. Does this mean denying medical treatment, ignoring the state of the environment, and all else? If you're putting Christ first, then you should have no worry, as he says in the bible, "I will do whatever you ask in my name" (John 14:13). Indeed, this is the thinking of many who prefer to rely on god instead of science. Somehow moderate believers will respond that Christ should be valued highly, but not above everything, and even many fundamentalists will not extend their 'Jesus or bust' philosophy to areas of health and safety.
But why not? The bible clearly supports Augustine's statement above, and even if you reject the infallibility of the bible, isn't faith something to be praised in all denominations of Christianity? I think you'd be hard-pressed to find a Christian who would not agree with the idea that the more one relies on god, the better their relationship with him will be. Any Christian who claims that one should not rely much on god is at odds with practically all of the bible and Christian theology. If Jesus and/or god don't merit this degree of faith to liberal Christians, then why even bother having faith at all? God could save you from your sin, but can't (or won't) help with some direction in your life?
This leads me to the ultimate problem behind the 'Jesus first' mantra. If you can't trust your god in any area of your life, why should I trust him even in one area of mine? Of course, this is a rhetorical question, because I consider unwavering devotion to be a bad idea and an immoral teaching. One reason why the story of Abraham and Isaac is often criticized by non-Christians is because it emphasizes this 'god above all' mentality better than anything else. Believers are quick to note that Abraham doesn't actually sacrifice Isaac, but it doesn't matter, because the real horror is in the blind faith that would lead a person to even consider killing their child under the orders of a god. Abraham undoubtedly put god before his own family and was rewarded and praised for it even centuries later. Today parents who would do the same will be prosecuted, thrown into mental hospitals, and treated like unstable lunatics, rightly so.
Putting Christ first means putting a halt on progress. The period in history when most of the world valued Christ above all else has been appropriately named the Dark Ages now. Many asked in the name of Christ, yet the door was not opened to them. Many put Christ before all others, and yet 'blessings' only came in the form of plagues and wars. Part of what makes Ingmar Bergman's film, The Seventh Seal, such a masterpiece is its title. In the book of Revelation, the seventh seal is silence in heaven, and nothing more accurately describes the Dark Ages. The approach of Augustine, Rick Warren, Pat Robertson, and other believers has been tried before, and all it yielded was disaster. We have a name for someone who demands his subjects to put him above all else: a tyrant. The Christian god is a tyrant in every sense of the word - threatening dissenters with unimaginable torment, commanding tribute in the form of worship, and generally looking after his own interests. The day when tyrants are to be valued above all is a dark day indeed.
Saturday, July 31, 2010
Clerk Shares Jesus With Robber
I see this sort of feel-good story in the same way I see the reports of miraculous survivals against the odds. When someone suffering from a terminal illness lives and attributes it to God, the other countless unlucky persons are usually never allowed to give their side of the story. Mostly because no god came through to save them. Likewise, for every tale of a courageous believer foiling a criminal's plans by ministering to them, there are countless dozens of unlucky others who were killed despite their efforts. Missionaries die all the time despite their efforts, and yet this is never counted as a strike against faith.
Maybe this blog entry will seem callous and heartless to some people, but it's worth asking why we count the hits and ignore the misses often times. I suspect that we don't count things fairly because we fear what the results might reveal to us. Random, indiscriminate circumstances. Then again, doesn't the bible say that God sends rain on both the righteous and the wicked? So what's all this nonsense about thinking that God's tweaking knobs behind every corner?